Hotel Mela Times Square

Very Poor
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : bed was comfy
  : This hotel switched our reservation 3 days before the trip and we were reassigned to a hotel in Koreatown. Very crowded area. Room was disgusting, sheets were too thin to get warm. There was a large hole burned into the carpet that had not been fixed.

Very Poor
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : Hotel did not exist
  : The hotel did not exist as a hotel upon our arrival from out of state!!!!!!!

Very Good
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple

Very Poor
Traveller Type:
  : Nothing
  : Firstly, we were informed with very little notice that our booking had been moved to the sister hotel Hotel Fifth Avenue with no explanation. Having booked this property nearly a year in advance this little notice gave us no choice but to take this booking in the sister property. When we arrived at the other hotel we were extremely disappointed. We were promised an upgraded room as a result of the hotel change which was not upheld and the problems only began there. On our first night, upon returning around 9pm to our room we discovered our keycards had been disabled and we were locked out of our prepaid (downgraded) room. When we inquired at reception as to why we were unable to access our room we were greeted by a very rude male staff member who insisted that we step away from his desk. He then informed us that the cleaning staff had requested we were locked out of our room as a result of a stain on the bedsheets. When we disputed the unsafe measures taken with accusation, he simply handed us a card to contact his manager. Upon contacting his manager, Kucuk Bag we were met with a similarly disappointing and dismissive response. He told us he would investigate it and inform us of his findings which he did not do. As three female travellers, we felt intimidated by the staff and unsafe in our surroundings, we felt from that point on we could not let anyone enter our room for fear of more false accusations and ridiculous consequences. As a results of this mess, the hotel took a $50 dollar deposit from us due to what cleaners deemed to be a stain on the sheet. I will never stay with the Rebel Hotel group again, for fear of a similar situation occurring.

Very Good
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : We stayed at the Hotel @5th Avenue as the Hotel Mela was getting some work done. Room was perfect for our needs, we were out and about so much that we didn't spend much time there but it was perfect for our needs. Location was fantastic, around the corner from Macys and close to a subway (Penn Station) We didn't have breakfast but there is plenty of eating spots close by.
  : A minor complaint that the elevator is slow, but that is a very small issue. Would be nice if there was a mini-fridge in the room but again this is not a major issue. We didn't have the AC on but when we did turn on to see what it was like, it was quite loud. It might be an issue if staying when it is hotter.